| Platinum | Dangerous Minds Brewing Co. |
| Gold | Peter's Pizzaria |
| Silver | Kosta's Greek Eatery |
| Bronze | Pasquale Pizza |
| Top Pick | Bedda Mia Ristorante & Pizzette |
| Top Pick | Carlucci's Trattoria & Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Little Italian Pizza |
| Top Pick | Phil's Heavenly Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pompano Pizza & Italian Eatery |